You Want it When?
Inside the Studio — By Kristy Miller on September 15, 2009 at 5:32 PMI’ve threatened to talk about this topic before but I have refrained, until today….
Can someone please explain to me how colorists are repeatedly supposed to color a book without art? Ok, I’m sounding a little cranky here, let’s back up.
As we all know, colorists get the art last (along with letterers.) We have to wait for it to be written, pencilled, inked, scanned, and sent to us. All of that obviously takes some time. Also, in there, is approvals and changes from editors or other people in the creative team which can also slow things down.
I really understand that, I do, but, how can we get the call/email Friday at 5 saying the art is going to be emailed to you, you’ll need to color it over the weekend and have it waiting for us on Monday morning so that we can get you corrections (‘cause we all know there will be corrections) and off to press by 1PM Eastern.
Then the art doesn’t come, for whatever reason, until Saturday afternoon (after you’ve hung by your email waiting all day.) Then you notice you are still missing 6 pages. After some checking you find out you’ll get those on Sunday–early we promise.
Then you spend your whole weekend working like a dog to meet the deadline. You are giving yourself an ulcer trying to get everything wrapped up Monday morning only to get the next call/email saying that the book that you thought was due Wed has been pushed back to Friday because the art is late and won’t be coming in until Wed late afternoon. Then on top of all that you get another call/email asking if you can squeeze in a cover (right now) so that it can get to Previews in the afternoon.
Ok, now I don’t want to offend anyone who works in these other fields, I get it is a trickle down theory BUT stand back while I vent for a minute….
Now, most of these titles, mini-series, graphic novels, story lines, etc. are planned out in advance. We have to coordinate all this with other departments, toys, movies, cons, whatever. So, at some point, early on in this process someone knows when this puppy should go to print and when it should come out on the stands. In some cases I’m pretty sure people know this up to a year in advance. And I’m not just talking large publishers, this is true of smaller publishers as well.
That being said, how come the colorist gets it 36 hours before press and have to speed though it, then we get blamed for missing things or it looking “rushed”–no kidding?!?
Not being on the other side of this very often I would like to know what sorts of deadlines, writers & pencillers get (inkers too but we can tell they are down to the wire with us most of the time.) Obviously, it depends on who you are. Some people get away with missing deadlines and some don’t. Sometimes thats due to fame or talent or friendship or whatever but looking at it from a money-making (or losing) side of things why is that?
Why do projects get green-lighted in March, written in April, pencilled & inked in May to end of June and colored on July 1st?
Here is another topic along these lines that bothers me. Why do we get the phone call on Friday at 5 and are expected to work all weekend when those giving the orders are scampering off for the weekend only to think about this again on Monday morning. Why is it assumed we are excited to give up our weekend (or holiday or whatever) and work while we know good and well you won’t be. Oh, right money. I remember now, they get a paycheck every two weeks no matter what. We only get a paycheck two weeks after we actually due some work.
I know there are a lot of caveats in this and things that go wrong along the way or even stories depending on other stories and therefore deadlines get pushed. When we first started in this business we wouldn’t accept projects until we had all the art. That way we could see all the art, get a feel for the book and story, and… wait for it… be creative and careful and kick-ass.
This was never the most smoothly run industry but, is is just me, or have things gotten worse in the last year?
Authors Note: Ok, this is really negative and I’m sorry but I’m tired, my tooth STILL hurts, and we’ve been working non-stop on crazy deadlines. I know, I know, I should be pleased that we have work and not bitching about the deadlines. I am pleased see my other article called “Working from the Couch.” One last little problem with all this… you work your butt off on these deadlines, then sit and twiddle your thumbs for a week (while you could be working on the next project) waiting for word that the art is finally coming and you can have 3 days this time–lucky you! Oops that was negative again, sorry. Feel free to yell at me in the comments.
Kristy Miller
VP, Development
Hi-Fi Design


Tweet This
Share on Facebook
Digg This
Bookmark
Stumble






12 Comments
i always look forward to reading your articles.
swazworth: I hope that is for good reasons.
The brutal honesty is always nice to hear.
This is a very well written article Kristy. As a freelance colorist I have been in that situation a few times just this year. One person expected twenty-two pages over night. Sadly I was forced to turn the job down, afterall I flat my own work and it would never get done in one night.
Why do you think people expect so much from us colorists?
A penciler, inker, writers are given so much more freedom and time.
I just don’t understand it. if it were the other way around would comics even exist?
Keep up the amazing work Kristy and I hope that tooth of yours starts to feel better soon.
- Tim
“You use a computer to color, doesn’t the computer really do most of the work? I mean, it’s a lot FASTER to work that way.”
an honest to GOD, real question I was asked by an editor. I think things have been getting progressively worse for about 2 years now. The most I EVER did for a publisher, was 13 pages overnight and ONLY because they agreed to pay me triple my page rate. The requests for that kind of turnaround only increased after that point and the page rates went down. I know of other colorists that have turned down work because of just stupidly insane deadlines, then watched the book not come out on time anyways because the “replacement” that was used, shockingly couldn’t color the pages in the requested turnaround time.
While I think we would all certainly welcome the money if it CAME on time from a publisher for doing work on crazy deadlines, I’m not so sure that we’re doing ourselves any favors by killing our bodies to meet such deadlines. I know that in the last 6 months, since I took a part time day job as an ad designer, my health has greatly improved by turning away crazy turnaround requests for coloring work
and just taking things I want to take on.
I know that the longer I go without cranking something out in a 42 hour marathon, the less and less I want to go BACK to cranking things out like that. Of course…then we get into questions like “at what age does a creator start to realize how hard comic deadlines are mentally, and physically, and how long after they have that realization, do they still have a burning desire to create anymore?”
Kristy,
this article wouldn’t happen to be inspired by last weekend’s big push, would it?
Jason,
how on earth did you get thirteen pages done overnight??
Kristy: yes, for very good reasons… i couldn’t have said it better than Rob did “The brutal honesty is always nice to hear.” i’m in the process of taking Brian’s class right now. so i’m not a professional colorist, but as some one who would like to be one day. (fingers crossed) it is nice to get straight talk on what to expect. the good with the bad, that is why i really look forward to reading your articles.
thanks
Steve: Last week, the week before, and you haven’t even seen the schedule for the next two weeks yet!!!!
Kristy,
Thank you for venting for those who cannot! Who do these people think you are? But, I mean, your company does have great work though…
and Jason,
I really can’t believe an editor asked that question!! Ugh! If they only knew the sacrifice and talent, oh,and TIME it takes to get these things done! Yes, yes, you use a computer to do the work, but it’s not like the computer turns itself on and just colors the work for you. And then “Poof” magically its done…no, no, no. That’s not right at all! Keep up the good work you guys!!!
Just blame the writer. Everybody else does!
I feel bad for you , Kristy . If I were you I wouldn’t stand that in the first place.
Ah the glamorous life of a pixel slinger! Brings out the masochist in all of us.